On Book Banning Zealots & Ostriches

UPDATE: Thanks everyone for your ongoing support and awesomeness, especially on the #SpeakLoudly Twitter thread! Keep reading and keep speaking loudly against book banning!

Most of you know I’m getting pretty riled up about this whole censorship thing. There was the Ellen Hopkins un-invite from the Humble Texas book event. The Stockton, MO banning of Sherman Alexie’s THE ABSOLUTELY TRUE DIARY OF A PART TIME INDIAN. Then the news that TWENTY BOY SUMMER was being challenged in a Missouri school library because one parent thought the title was “promiscuous.”

One parent’s challenge of TBS isn’t a big deal, really. But it speaks to the larger issues of censorship that I talked about last week, and that’s why I was so upset.

But then I got an update on the “minor” TBS situation, and it’s actually much worse than I thought.

Dr. Wesley Scroggins, a fundamentalist Christian and parent in Republic, MO, has issued a 29-page missive to the Republic school board calling for the removal of TBS, SLAUGHTERHOUSE FIVE, and most shocking of all — Laurie Halse Anderson’s SPEAK — a book about the date rape of a teen girl which Scroggins calls “soft pornography.” Not surprisingly, he’s also fighting to kill the sex ed curriculum, removing any pamphlets that discuss HIV or condoms and disallowing teachers to talk about reproduction and sex, stating that “…children at the middle school are being introduced to concepts such as homosexuality, oral sex, anal sex and specific instructions on how to use a condom and have sex.” Note that in Republic, kids (or their parents) can opt out of the sex ed curriculum, which is abstinence-based, but that’s not good enough for Scroggins. Apparently he doesn’t want anyone unmarried and under the age of 25 to know about “female parts.”

You all know how I feel about the head in the sand mentality, right? Because I’m sure us girls never even knew we had vaginas (yes, Dr. Scroggins, it’s called a vagina) until we took sex ed and learned “how to use a condom and have sex.”

*rolls eyes*

Sex and girl parts aside, he’s also got a problem with the school’s teaching of the Constitution and lots of history and science books that teach anything other than the strictest Christian interpretation of those subjects.

In his whackadoo-from-the-zoo article, “Filthy books demeaning to Republic education,” he says this about TWENTY BOY SUMMER:

This book glorifies drunken teen parties, where teen girls lose their clothes in games of strip beer pong. In this book, drunken teens also end up on the beach, where they use their condoms to have sex. I confronted the school board with these issues at the June school board meeting. As far as I know, nothing has been done to address these issues to date. This is unacceptable, considering that most of the school board members and administrators claim to be Christian. How can Christian men and women expose children to such immorality? Parents, it is time you get involved!

I’m not going to spend a lot of time defending my book other than to say what those who’ve read it already know — despite its lighthearted title, TBS is not about parties and sex. It’s about two girls struggling in the aftermath of a major tragedy, with grieving parents and unfamiliar situations and secrets that threaten to kill their friendship. It’s a scary world for them, and my job as a writer is to tell their story honestly, without judgment. And I know I’ve done my job because I hear from teens who’ve experienced devastating loss, and they tell me how much the book meant to them or how they could relate to the characters more than they can relate to their own friends somtimes. One email like that is all I needed to know that I did what I set out to do.

But here’s the thing that really gets me about Scoggins’ comments: When he says, “Parents, it is time you get involved,” he’s not really asking parents to get involved in what might actually be a good discussion and healthy debate. Truly asking for parental involvement would mean encouraging parents to read the books in question, discuss issues and themes with their kids, and come to their own decisions about what’s best for their own families. Scroggins is just calling people out, bating them with accusations of being immoral or “unchristian,” looking for a few good upstanding parents to join his lynch mob.

(And another kick in the ass? According to comments on the article [still trying to find out the source and confirm — anyone know?], his own children are home schooled. If that’s true, this guy is just stirring up shit for other people’s kids, all under the banner of his version of Jesus.)

So we’re back to the whole issue of what censorship teaches our kids, and it’s not something I’m willing to stand for.

If you’re riled up about this to, here’s how you can get involved:

- Retweet this post by clicking the retweet button to the right
– Blog about your thoughts and reaction
- Join the #SpeakLoudly thread on Twitter
- Voice your opinion on Scroggins’ original article here
- Write a letter to the editor of Springfield’s News-Leader
- Write to the administrators in the Republic school district

You can also check out Laurie Halse Anderson’s response to the nonsense here: This guy thinks SPEAK is pornography

And don’t forget to enter to win a Wesley Scroggins Filthy Books Prize Pack now through Friday, September 24!

Thanks everyone for your support!

48 thoughts on “On Book Banning Zealots & Ostriches

      • LHA is my number one favorite issue author. Speak has a special affinity to me, something I wasn’t able to blog about but I will support this book and really any challenged book to the ends of the earth. I went to my shelf. I have TBS! Reading it tonight.

      • Sarah, I’d never even heard of SPEAK before reading this post by you! Given how many teenaged girls are date-raped and otherwise sexually assaulted or pressured into sexual situations by their peers (often other girls) it’s so important for teenaged girls to get actual TRUTH about it all. Any book that addresses the topic is definitely NOT pornography unless you get hawt at the idea of raping a girl. I guess this so-called Christian man gets into rape. Figures.

        G-d (*MY* G-d anyway) would be disgusted with this man using His Name to condemn a book that condemns rape. At least I assume SPEAK condemns it ;-) Now I shall have to go off to my county library and read a copy. Thanks!

      • I *love* SPEAK. This book is an inspiration to me, both as a ‘writer in the making’ and as a human being. I can’t believe anyone would want to keep this book out of schools! What is this man thinking?! I haven’t read TBS but I’m looking forward to it. Thanks for this post. People need to hear the other side of the story, which in this case, is just the plain truth.

  1. Pingback: Hell Hath No Fury Like the Book Community Scorned « Reclusive Bibliophile

    • I know! If that’s true, it just makes me think… wow. This guy has a lot of free time on his hands. And he’s doing all this from his work computer and work email.

  2. That guy really made me mad. It’s like he didn’t even pick up TBS or Speak. He just flipped through the pages, looking for something to criticize.

    I read Speak when I was in ninth grade, and I thought it was a powerful read, one that many rape victims could relate to. How a man, especially one who claims to be Christian could say such a thing, comparing rape to pornography, it just makes me sick.

    And then once he started talking about TBS, I knew he had lost his mind, because as you said, and as many people who have read the book will say, Twenty Boy Summer isn’t about sex or condoms or parties. It’s about two girls coping, and what is wrong with that?

    Nothing.

    *sighs* This guy seriously has problems with sex and the word vagina.

  3. I completely agree with you, Sarah. I’m sick to my stomach after reading what he said. I’ve blogged, joined Twitter and plan on writing a letter as well. Thanks for posting this and he knows nothing about TBS. It’s one of the most beautiful books I’ve ever read.

  4. You pretty much said everything I was thinking. It’s obvious this person did not read Twenty Boy Summer or Speak. To refer to rape as soft core pornography is beyond disturbing. I don’t even know what to say to a terrible comment like that.

    Banning books has never made any sense to me. If you don’t want your kid reading something then that’s your decision but don’t force others to do so as well.

    Hiding things from teens never achieved anything. Taking sex-ed out of a school is one of the worst ideas ever. Teaching students how to use condoms is not a way of saying “go out and sleep with everyone in your path.”

    This kind of stuff infuriates me beyond belief. It’s children that are restricted and uneducated on particular topics that often find themselves in situations in life that could have been avoided.

  5. I just reserved a copy of SPEAK and read the summary. WOW. How come there weren’t any books like *that* when *I* was a teenager?!! (in the 1970s) The best book I read in the 10-12 yo age range was SUMMER OF MY GERMAN SOLDIER which was, actually, pretty awesome. It’s one of only 2 books I kept from my childhood, the other being a fairytale collection ;)

    I can’t wait to read SPEAK. Thanks so much for mentioning it, Sarah. My library system has something like 50 copies (yeah, can you believe it?) but a handful are tagged for storage and only 2 are checked in. I’m 4th in the request queue. I’ll have to wait a week or two but sounds like it’ll be well-worth it!

  6. Pingback: Is Speak Pornographic? | Bookalicious

  7. Jeebus, Sarah, what a mess. I’m so sorry that some whackaloon with his head up his ass has nothing better to do with his time than stir up this kind of hornet’s nest.

    Your books, Laurie’s books, Ellen’s books, and so very many other books are so important to have available for our kids. Every time I think of someone trying to keep a book out of my son’s or daughter’s hands, I start frothing at the mouth. That kind of presumption speaks of an overprivileged (and completely undeserved) air of entitlement.

  8. Pingback: Win a Wesley Scroggins Filthy Books Prize Pack! « Sarah Ockler, Author

  9. Pingback: Speak Loudly | Escape Through the Pages

  10. Imagine if people took the time to read books that their kids want to read… and thoughtfully discussed them with their kids afterwards. Imagine how different our world could be.

    I’m sorry you have to go through this, Sarah. Know you have a legion of love and support behind you.

  11. One should be made to read a book before banning it, OR burning it! Ignorance and intolerance seem to be grappling with Reality. Please. Read. Books.

  12. Pingback: #SpeakLoudly about Censorship « Readligion

  13. Thank you so much for posting this. I am one of the many
    who found her voice because of SPEAK and I was appalled by the recent events. I haven’t read TWENTY BOY SUMMER, but I just ordered it from Amazon and am looking forward to it!

  14. Pingback: Back to the future/Banned in the USA | Top Of My Head

  15. Sarah, you know this librarian supports you and I’m fighting for these books! This is crazy and I want you to know that there is a big support for the books in Missouri right now!

  16. Pingback: 20 Boy Summer has been challenged–win a copy here! « For one mentally ill minute

  17. Scroggins and the like want to protect vulnerable people but it is better to do so by educating them than shielding them. After all, that is what school is for! It disturbs me that he is more upset by the though of children finding out about the darker side to life through books, than first-hand. Then, when it’s too late, where does banning books lead to but ignorance, shame and fear?

  18. Pingback: Lessons Learned from Fahrenheit 451 About Censorship | WebLiterate.Com

  19. Pingback: CAUTION! WARNING! Books in this library will offend you! « Teens @ CCPL&IC

  20. He’s just another example of the type of person who just buries his head in the sand and pretends this stuff doesn’t happen. It makes far more sense to read a book like this and discuss it openly with your children. This will help them to feel comfortable about talking to you about sensitive subject matters and opens the doors to a healthy bond.

  21. It’s unbelievable what some people will do to try and lecture others about what is a “good” and “bad” book. Writers use the freedom of expression to discuss, inform, teach, share and reach out to people. How could he possibly have an issue with Speak, which is an incredibly important book for young adults to understand the horrors of rape and peer pressure? Censorship is too often a mindless, fear mongering monster that attacks books without actual thought or reason behind and stifles free thought. Banning books doesn’t help solve the social problems we face nor does it correct them. We need brave authors who are not afraid to tell it like it is.Writing about sensitive or controversial issues is not the same thing as exploiting them. Rape=pornography, really? Really?

    I hope people are more empowered to read these books because of Mr. Scroggin’s uninformed editorial. I’m truly inspired by your good attitude and resolve to continue promoting the banned books and fighting back against censorship, especially using social media to get the word out. #SpeakLoudly is brilliant!

  22. Pingback: I Speak Loudly for SPEAK: Video « Sarah Ockler, Author

  23. whilst I reaaaaaally dislike this kind of zealot – why give him any attention – the danger is that you could risk giving him a national platform from which to spout his twisted hate.. These people will never change their minds or bow to any pressure – they just up the ante and end up like the Westboro Baptist Church and waving placards on street corners, telling grieving parents that their sons died in Iraq as punishment for homosexuality..

  24. You know, I just read Twenty Boy Summer last week, and I absolutely loved it. I had put it off for a while because I thought the title sounded loose, I suppose, but once I read what it was about, I knew I had to read it. Here was my review…http://tinyurl.com/2cpvsk8

    Mr. Scroggins used a platform of religion to propagate what he believed the correct morals and values are that should be taught in schools, and I absolutely loathe that he did. I don’t believe in banning books or censorship. The only good thing I believe came of this was the fact that so many more people are interested in these titles now, and I believe the opposite of what he had hoped for happened :)

  25. Good for you, Sarah! I get super riled up over censorship issues as well. Which is why I’m co-hosting a Banned Books Event here in Milwaukee during Banned Books Week. I shared your link via our FB page: http://www.facebook.com/bannedmke#%21/bannedmke and Tweeted, too!

    In all the work I’ve done for our event, I’ve found that many of the challenged books for last year happened right here in my home state of Wisconsin. That terrifies me.

  26. Pingback: OIF Blog » More Missouri book challenges – “Speak,” two other books in Republic row

  27. Pingback: L’esprit d’escalier » Banned Books Week 2010

  28. TBS and SPEAK sound like amazing books. I can’t wait to read them. I want to THANK Mr. Scroggins for bringing them to my attention or I might have missed out on some really great stories. *off to the bookstore*

  29. Pingback: Bloggers Speak Out – link collection | Escape Through the Pages

  30. Pingback: Banned Books Week – Support a Challenged or Banned Author & Giveaway! « Let The Words Flow

  31. Pingback: Speak Loudly | Karen Woodward

  32. Pingback: Think For Yourself & Let Others Do the Same « Teens @ Sewickley Library

  33. Pingback: One Doesn’t Speak for an Entire Population: On Banned Books Week | Bri Meets Books

  34. Pingback: Bloggers Speak Out (Giveaway of Speak) | Reading Through Life

  35. Pingback: Twenty Boy Summer – Sarah Ockler | Absolutely Obsessed

  36. Hi Sarah, my name is Tara and I’ve been interested in the issue of book banning and challenging for a while now. I read Twenty Boy Summer and loved it. This question may seem a little redundant because you write about how riled up you are, but how does it feel to have someone challenge something that you put so much effort and time into?
    Why can’t people accept literature for what it is? And just not read it if they don’t like it or approve of it….

Comments are closed.